CASE STUDY- CURRENCY WAR
Introduction
Currency war, also known as competitive devaluation, is a condition in international affairs where countries compete against each other to achieve a relatively low exchange rate for their home currency, so as to help their domestic industry by simulating exports and creating more jobs. If more and more nations adopt this kind of foreign exchange policy, the interest conflicts between them will get worse, potentially damaging the trade relations between them.
The aim of this case study is to understand the reasons for devaluation of currency and mechanisms for the same. We shall also discuss how the recent financial crisis led to competitive devaluation of currencies.
Reasons for Devaluation
- Reduce Trade Deficit : Devaluation has been advised by the IMF from the early 1980s as a potential solution for developing nations that are consistently spending more on imports than they earn on exports. A lower value for the home currency will raise the price for imports while reducing the price for exports. This encourages more production to occur domestically, which raises employment and GDP.
- Unemployment : Devaluation can be especially attractive as a solution to unemployment when other options like increased public spending are ruled out due to high public debt and also when a country has a balance of payment imbalance which a devaluation would help correct.
- Build Foreign reserves: A reason for preferring devaluation common among emerging economies is that maintaining a relatively low exchange rate helps them build up their foreign exchange reserves, which can protect them against future financial crisis.
- Tool to fight recession : The ability of currency devaluation to result in export led growth and reduce unemployment has made it a commonly sought after option during recession. The Great depression(1929), Asian crisis (1997) and the current global financial crisis(2007) are examples where this method was used to counter the recession.
Potential impact of Devaluation
Devaluation can lead to a reduction in citizen's material standard of living as their purchasing power is reduced both when they buy imports and when they travel abroad.It can add to inflationary pressure. Devaluation can make international debt servicing more expensive if debts are denominated in a foreign currency, and it can discourage foreign investors.
International conditions required for currency war
For a widespread currency war to occur a large proportion of significant economies must wish to devalue their currencies at once. This has so far only happened during a global economic downturn.
Individual currency devaluation has to involve a corresponding rise in value for at least one other currency. The corresponding rise will generally be spread across all other currencies and so unless the devaluing country has a huge economy and is substantially devaluing, the offsetting rise for any individual currency will tend to be small. In normal times other countries are often content to accept a small rise in the value of their own country or at worst be indifferent to it.
However if much of the world is suffering from a recession, from low growth or are pursuing strategies which depends on a favorable balance of payments, nations can begin competing with each other to devalue. Once a small number of countries begin intervening to this can trigger corresponding interventions from others as they strive to prevent further deterioration in their export competitiveness.
Mechanism for Devaluation
- A state's central bank can still intervene in the markets to effect a devaluation – if it sells its own currency to buy other currencies then this will cause the value of its own currency to fall - a practice common with states that have a managed exchange rate regime.
- Quantitative Easing: Less directly, if a central bank indulges in quantitative easing as had become common in 2009 and 2010, this tends to lead to a fall in the value of its currency even if the bank does not directly buy any foreign assets. This can be done by creating money and injecting it into the domestic economy with open market operations.
Quantitative easing can act to devalue a country's currency in two indirect ways. Firstly it can encourage speculators to bet that the currency will decline in value. Secondly, the large increase in the domestic money supply will lower domestic interest rates, often they will become much lower than interest rates in countries not practicing quantitative easing. This creates the conditions for a carry trade, where market participants can have an earner by borrowing in the currency of the country practicing quantitative easing, and then lend within a country with a relatively high rate of interest. Because they are effectively selling the currency being used for quantitative easing on the international markets, this can increase the supply of the currency and hence push down its value
- A third method is for authorities simply to talk down the value of their currency, by hinting at future action that will discourage speculators from betting on a future rise, though this method sometimes has little discernible effect.
Competitive devaluation has been rare through most of history as countries have generally preferred to maintain a high value for their currency, have been content to allow its value to be set by the markets or have participated in systems of managed exchanges rates. However , there are prominent occasions in the history such as the Great depression (1929) , Asian crisis (1997) and Financial crisis(2007) where competitive devaluation was used as a significant tool to fight recession.
Global financial crisis (2007) and Currency war
By 2009 some of the conditions required for a currency war had returned, with a severe economic downturn seeing global trade in that year decline by 12% . There was a widespread concern among advanced economies about the size of their deficits, so they increasingly joined emerging economies in viewing export led growth as their ideal strategy. There were three important situations witnessed.
The biggest one is over China’s unwillingness to allow the yuan to rise more quickly. For much of 2009 and 2010, China has been under pressure from the US to allow the yuan to appreciate. Between June and October 2010, China allowed a 2% appreciation of the yuan, but there were concerns from Western observers that China only relaxes her intervention when under heavy pressure. With global economy doing well, China was able to abandon her dollar peg in 2005, allowing a substantial appreciation of the Yuan up to 2007, while still increasing her exports. The dollar peg was re-established as the financial crises began to reduce China's export orders. The fixed peg was not abandoned until just before the June 2010 G20 meeting, after which the yuan appreciated by about 1%, only to slowly devalue again until further US pressure in September 2010 when the yuan again began relatively steep appreciation.
A second flashpoint is the rich world’s monetary policy, particularly the prospect that central banks soon restart printing money to buy government bonds.( quantitative easing) The dollar fell as financial markets expected the Federal Reserve to act fastest and most boldly. The euro soared as officials at the European Central Bank showed least enthusiasm for such a shift. In China’s eyes (and, those of many other emerging-market governments), quantitative easing creates a gross distortion in the world economy as investors rush elsewhere, especially into emerging economies, in search of higher yields. These emerging economies cry that they are innocent victims, as their currencies are forced up by foreign capital flooding into their markets .
A third area of contention comes from how the developing countries respond to these capital flows. Rather than let their exchange rates soar, many governments intervened to buy foreign currency, or imposed taxes on foreign capital inflows. Brazil doubled a tax on foreign purchases of its domestic debt, Thailand announced a new 15% withholding tax for foreign investors in its bonds and interventions were seen from South Korea and Chile to prevent currency appreciation.
What can be done?
All this leaves one big question - what can countries like the US and UK do to reduce their deficits?
One option is austerity. Consumers and companies are already cutting back on borrowing. If governments do the same, the entire country borrows less, and its deficit reduces. The problem is that austerity in the deficit countries can lead to recession.
Another option is looser money. But with interest rates at zero, central banks are left to resort to quantitative easing - printing money and using it to buy up debts, or intervening directly in currency markets.
But these are limited tool.
Many in the US Congress are lobbying for trade sanctions against China. But that raises a spectre that is haunting the G20 meeting - the ghost of the 1930s, when protectionism started by the US led to a collapse of trade that was a big contributor to the Great Depression.
Points to Ponder
One might think that the world could put Great Depression analogies behind it. But they are back, and with more force than ever. Now the fear is that currency warfare, leading to tariffs and retaliation, could cause disruptions to the international trading system as serious as those of the 1930’s. Thus, leaving us with the following questions
· Is currency devaluation an effective tool to fight recession for a global economy?
· Is there a better way to organize the world currencies? Or in other words, Does the global economy need a new monetary system - the set of rules, norms and institutions that govern the world’s currencies and the flow of capital across borders. ? The present system has fostered the creation of vast foreign-exchange reserves, particularly by emerging economies. These huge reserves offend economic logic, since they mean poor countries, which should have abundant investment opportunities of their own, are lending cheaply to richer ones, mainly America. Also, many politicians argue that a financial system in which emerging economies can suffer floods of foreign capital cannot be the best basis for long-term growth.
· Is the dominance of the dollar as a reserve currency and America’s management of it a serious concern ? The bulk of foreign-exchange transactions and reserves are in dollars, even though the United States accounts for only 24% of global GDP. A disproportionate share of world trade is conducted in dollars. To many people believe that the supremacy of the greenback in commerce, commodity pricing and official reserves is not sensible. Not only does it fail to reflect the realities of the world economy; it leaves others vulnerable to America’s domestic monetary policy.
References
· Wikipedia (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Currency_war )
· The Economist (http://www.economist.com/node/17414511?story_id=E1_TSQTQVTT )
· BBC News (http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-11608719 )
· Investopedia ( http://www.investopedia.com/articles/economics/08/currency-crises.asp )
· http://www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/eichengreen23/English
Comments